Cattle mutilations
The Skeptoid podcast traces claims of livestock found with precise cuts to older fears, which became tied to aliens in the sixties.
These are real animal deaths on real ranches. No identified person should be blamed for them on the strength of the claims here.
According to Wikipedia, a mother and son, Agnes and Harry King, reportedly found the family's three-year-old horse dead on 9 September 1967. The skin and flesh had been removed from its head and neck, and the cuts looked very precise to King. According to Harry, there was no blood at the scene, and the account also notes a strong medicinal smell in the air.
The researcher Bill Ellis, quoted by Skeptoid, dates the first modern mutilation to the early twentieth century in England, where mutilated cattle caused alarm that a wolf was at large. Across the decades such cases were put down to Satanists, hippies and lunatics, among other culprits, before aliens got the blame in the sixties.
A natural explanation comes from Dunning, who told the Daily Yonder that after an animal dies in a field, insects and birds go first for exposed soft tissue: eyes, lips, tongue and genitals. A dead animal has no blood pressure, so there is no bleeding, and bare skin dries and tightens, giving the look of a scalpel cut. Blowfly eggs can hatch in as little as 10 hours, and maggots can leave clean, dry bone a few hours later.
The cases drew official attention. An FBI file says the District Attorney in Santa Fe reported applying for a grant from the Law Enforcement Assistance Administration, and that the grant was then made, to fund a special unit under the New Mexico District Attorney. Kenneth M. Rommel, formerly an FBI agent, was appointed to head it. The La Grande Observer reports that sheriff's detectives in Crook County, long-time ranchers and a veterinarian from Prineville who looked at material in a continuing case said the deaths had them stumped.
"On September 9, 1967, Agnes King and her son Harry reportedly found the dead body of their three-year-old horse. The horse's head and neck had been skinned and defleshed, and the body displayed cuts that, to King, looked very precise. No blood was at the scene, according to Harry, and a strong medicinal odor was in the air."
- Cattle Mutilation (Skeptoid #456), Skeptoid
- Alien Experiment, Violent Crime or Natural Occurrence: Cattle Mutilations in the West Continue, The Daily Yonder
- Mysterious Oregon cattle mutilations perplex detectives, La Grande Observer
- Animal Mutilation, FBI file part 5 (full text), Internet Archive (FBI Vault)