Uncanny Atlas
Browse/Somewhere You Can Go/The Bennington Triangle
Disputed

The Bennington Triangle

WhenNovember 1945 (first disappearance)
WhereGlastenbury Mountain, Vermont
DoorSomewhere You Can Go
Our judgementObscurity 2 of 7

Citro gave the name Bennington Triangle to a run of disappearances around Glastenbury Mountain in Vermont, over five years from 1945.

Before you read on

These are real people who went missing, and their families and the authorities treated the cases as missing persons. The Triangle grouping is a later label.

Citro took the name Bennington Triangle from the Bermuda Triangle. He says it is no literal triangle but a span of wild, thickly wooded land about Glastenbury Mountain where several odd events occurred. Bennington is close by.

The first person to vanish from the area was Middie Rivers, an outdoorsman aged 74, who strayed from his camp, where he was hunting, in November 1945. Paula Jean Welden, an American college student, disappeared on 1 December 1946 while walking the Long Trail in Vermont. Wikipedia says errors by local sheriffs in the investigation brought about the founding of the Vermont State Police, and her fate remains unsolved. In Wikipedia's account of the man it calls Tedford, nobody told police he was missing until a week afterwards, when the head of the Bennington Soldiers' Home reported it on December 8. Newspapers said he was mentally ill, and his family said he was despondent about going back to Bennington. The author Tony Jinks says the popular belief is that he vanished from a bus, but that a week separates his last sighting from the report that he was missing.

A man quoted in The Berkshire Eagle says the first newspaper mention of sinister Native American legends on Glastenbury, or a burial ground there, came in 1981, in a Vermont paper, in the same period as Poltergeist and the Amityville Horror. The Triangle label itself was applied later to disappearances across five years.

From the primary source
"Paula Jean Welden (born October 19, 1928—disappeared December 1, 1946) was an American college student who disappeared while walking on the Long Trail hiking route in Vermont. Local sheriffs were criticized for errors made in the investigation, which led to the creation of the Vermont State Police (VSP). Welden's fate remains unsolved and was one of several unexplained disappearances in the same area, dubbed the "Bennington Triangle," during a five-year span."
Wikipedia, Disappearance of Paula Jean WeldenRead the source →
Also told in