The Times attack on Ballechin House
On 8 June 1897 The Times printed an article that dismissed the investigation of the haunting of Ballechin House.
Ballechin House was the subject of a psychical investigation led by Ada Goodrich Freer for the Society for Psychical Research. Reports of haunting there went back to 1876, according to the Stewart Society. Shortly after the tenancy ended, on 8 June 1897, The Times printed an article scathing about the investigation.
The article was anonymous. Wikipedia attributes it to J. Callender Ross, a visitor who had stayed at the house. The writer insisted the phenomena were plumbing noises or the work of other inhabitants, and called the methods perfunctory and absurd.
The society later removed material about the investigation from a volume of its Proceedings and denounced Freer. Frederic Myers, at first supportive, wrote to The Times that he greatly doubted the case.
"J. Callender Ross who had stayed at the house stated in The Times that there was no evidence for any supernatural disturbances and considered the whole investigation to be fraudulent.[10] The SPR later removed material from a volume of their Proceedings on the investigation and denounced Freer. Psychical researcher Frederic W. H. Myers who was originally supportive of the investigation wrote in a letter to The Times he "greatly doubt[ed] whether there was anything supernormal" at the house.[11]"
- The Haunting of Ballechin House, Newcastle University Special Collections
- The Haunting of Ballechin House: Ghosts, Controversy, and the Fall of Ada Goodrich-Freer, Haunted History Chronicles (podcast page)
- Research in the Field: Ada Goodrich Freer and Fiona Macleod, Palgrave Macmillan (Springer)
- History of the Stewarts: Ballechin House, The Stewart Society